How Does Stock Market Volatility Impact the Value of Your Business?

< Back to insights

In times of extreme volatility in the stock market, businesses often face challenges in understanding their true value. This is especially true for private companies, which do not have the transparency or liquidity of publicly traded firms. The fluctuations in stock prices, economic uncertainty, and shifting investor sentiment can complicate the valuation process. However, while the task may seem daunting, there are still reliable methods to determine the value of a private company in such turbulent times.

Understanding the Impact of Market Volatility

Volatility in the stock market often signals significant changes in investor sentiment, economic outlooks, or unforeseen events (e.g., geopolitical tensions or natural disasters). This can affect a private company’s valuation, even though it isn’t directly listed on a public exchange. The market’s reaction to these events can create shifts in industry valuations, alter risk assessments, or change capital access conditions for private companies.

For private firms, stock market volatility doesn’t always correlate directly with their financial performance or growth prospects. However, it often influences:

• Investor Appetite: During periods of volatility, private companies may face reduced interest from investors or an increase in demands for discounts on valuations due to perceived risks.
• Access to Capital: A volatile stock market can affect a company’s ability to raise new capital, especially if the firm plans to rely on the public market for an eventual exit (e.g., through an IPO).
• Market Comparables: Volatility can distort the comparables used in valuation (such as industry multiples or peer group analysis), as public company stock prices may not accurately reflect the underlying fundamentals.

Given these factors, valuing a private company during extreme market volatility requires careful consideration of both external market dynamics and the company’s internal fundamentals.

Key Methods to Value a Private Company in a Volatile Market

Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method

The DCF method is one of the most widely used techniques for valuing a private company. The DCF method estimates the present value of a company based on its projected future cash flows. These future cash flows are then discounted to account for the time value of money and risk.

During periods of market volatility, adjustments to the DCF model might be necessary:

• Risk Adjustments: The discount rate, or the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) may need to be increased to reflect the higher risk premiums demanded by investors during volatile periods. Increased volatility in the stock market could lead to higher perceived risks in a company’s future earnings.
• Cash Flow Sensitivity: In times of extreme volatility, it is crucial to revisit the assumptions about future cash flows. It’s important to consider how macroeconomic factors—such as inflation, interest rates, and supply chain disruptions—might affect the company’s revenues, margins, and expenses.

Guideline Public Company Method

The guideline public company method compares a private company to similar publicly traded companies to derive a valuation multiple (such as a enterprise value-to-EBITDA multiple). However, during periods of extreme volatility, market comparables can be tricky to apply:

Adjustment for Market Conditions: When using comparables, it is critical to adjust for the market volatility. For example, you might look at historical average multiples during stable periods, rather than relying on recent, highly volatile market multiples. You could also assess a range of multiples to account for the uncertainty in market conditions.

Earnings Volatility: Stock price movements may not always reflect the intrinsic value of a business but rather market sentiment. As a result, comparables may become distorted if market volatility causes extreme stock price swings unrelated to fundamentals.

Guideline Transaction Method

This method involves analyzing past transactions of similar companies to derive value. The major challenge during volatile times is that the most recent transactions may have occurred under very different market conditions, skewing the results.

• Transaction Timing: Consider whether the precedent transactions you’re looking at were conducted in a more stable market or whether they were influenced by volatility, which could distort the results.
• Adjusting for Current Conditions: Similar to using market comparables, precedent transactions analysis during volatile periods requires adjusting for the change in market conditions. If possible, try to look at deals completed prior to the current volatility to get a more stable baseline.

Asset-Based Methods

For companies that are asset-heavy or are in industries where assets (e.g., real estate, equipment, etc.) are key drivers of value, an asset-based method may be effective. These methods calculate a company’s value by summing the current value of its assets, while subtracting liabilities.

During periods of volatility, asset-based valuations can be helpful because it focuses on tangible elements of the business that may be less influenced by short-term market movements. However, it is important to note that this approach may understate the value of intangible assets such as trade names or customer relationships, which can be more volatile but still play a significant role in a company’s overall worth.

Considering Qualitative Factors During Volatility

While quantitative methods such as DCF and market comparables are important, qualitative factors should also be taken into account when valuing a private company during volatile periods. These factors can provide insight into the company’s ability to weather market storms or capitalize on opportunities in times of uncertainty.

• Management Team: A strong, experienced management team can significantly impact a company’s resilience during market turbulence. Assessing leadership’s track record and strategic vision is vital, as a capable team can navigate through volatility more effectively.
• Competitive Positioning: Companies with strong competitive advantages, unique intellectual property, or a dominant market position may be better positioned to endure market fluctuations. Conversely, companies that are highly dependent on market conditions or have limited differentiation may be at greater risk.
• Industry Trends: Industry-specific factors can have a huge influence on a company’s performance. For example, during an economic downturn, companies in consumer discretionary industries may suffer, while those in essential services or healthcare may see less impact.

Sensitivity and Scenario Analyses

Given the inherent uncertainty during periods of extreme volatility, conducting sensitivity and scenario analyses is crucial. This approach involves testing how different assumptions, such as growth rates, discount rates, or exit multiples, impact a company’s valuation under various scenarios.

For example, in a volatile market, a private company might want to model both an optimistic scenario (where the market stabilizes quickly) and a pessimistic one (where volatility continues or worsens). This helps investors and business owners understand the potential range of values for the business and make more informed decisions.

Conclusion

Valuing a private company during extreme stock market volatility is a challenging task, but by carefully selecting the appropriate valuation methods and considering both quantitative and qualitative factors, it is possible to arrive at a reasonable estimate of value. Adjusting for market conditions, focusing on fundamentals, and using scenario analysis can provide a more nuanced and reliable valuation. Ultimately, the goal is to avoid letting short-term market fluctuations obscure the long-term potential of the business and ensure that the valuation reflects both current uncertainties and the company’s true worth.

Learn More

To learn more about how stock market volatility impacts the value of your business, contact Gina Miller at 678.892.6306 or Brett Dixon at 770.790.6479.

Back to insights