How Should Contractors Account for Retainage to Protect Cash Flow and Reporting Accuracy?
Most U.S. real estate funds are organized as partnerships for federal income tax purposes. The partnership generally does not pay federal income tax itself.
Instead, each investor is allocated a share of income, gain, loss, deductions, and credits, whether or not the fund distributes cash. This distinction matters: a foreign investor can owe U.S. tax on allocated income even when the cash remains inside the fund.
When a fund conducts a U.S. trade or business, a foreign partner is treated as conducting that business as well. Income connected with that activity is effectively connected income, or ECI. For partnership tax real estate funds, ECI commonly includes net rental income, operating income, and gain from the sale of U.S. real property interests.
ECI is generally taxed on a net basis after allowable deductions, including depreciation, interest, property taxes, management costs, and other properly allocable expenses. Nonresident individuals report ECI on Form 1040-NR, while foreign corporations generally use Form 1120-F. The investor’s Schedule K-1 and related statements provide the tax information needed for the return.
A partnership with ECI allocable to a foreign partner generally must pay section 1446 withholding during the year, even if the fund makes no distribution. The withholding rate is generally 37% for noncorporate foreign partners and 21% for corporate foreign partners. These payments are prepayments of the investor’s U.S. tax, not necessarily the final liability.
The partnership reports its withholding liability on Form 8804 and provides each foreign partner Form 8805. The investor attaches Form 8805 to its U.S. return to claim the withholding credit. A foreign partner may provide Form 8804-C to identify partner-level deductions or losses that could reduce withholding. A partnership that receives a Form 8804-C from a foreign partner is not obligated to consider the Form 8804-C in computing the 1446 tax due with respect to that foreign partner.
The share of partnership income is determined under the partnership agreement and U.S. tax allocation rules, not simply by cash received. Depreciation and interest may reduce current taxable income, while special allocations must have substantial economic effect. Losses may be limited by tax basis, at-risk, passive activity, and other limitations, and unused losses may carry forward.
Foreign investor real estate tax rules also require attention to state filings, state withholding, composite returns, and differences between federal and state depreciation. Requirements vary by property location and investor type.
A separate rule applies when the foreign partner sells the fund interest. IRC § 864(c)(8)(A) provides that gain or loss on the sale or exchange of a partnership interest is treated as effectively connected to the extent of the partner’s share of gain or loss that would have been ECI if the partnership had sold all of its assets at fair market value on the sale date. Complementing that rule, IRC § 1446(f)(1) generally requires the transferee to withhold 10 percent of the amount realized on the disposition if any portion of the gain would be ECI under IRC § 864(c)(8), subject to exceptions such as a nonforeign affidavit under IRC § 1446(f)(2).
Because foreign investors real estate structures can create tax without matching cash, investors should review projected allocations, withholding, distribution policies, treaty eligibility, ownership structure, and exit provisions before committing capital. Proper planning helps align withholding with expected liability and reduces refund delays, filing surprises, and avoidable compliance problems.
Transfer Pricing is usually not the core issue in a plain-vanilla fund investment, but it can become relevant where related-party financing, management fees, or cross-border service arrangements affect taxable income. Transfer Pricing Enforcement may also matter if the fund uses related-party structures that shift income, deductions, or asset value across jurisdictions.
Conclusion
In short, foreign investors are usually taxed on their share of partnership income from U.S. real estate funds as ECI, with mandatory fund-level withholding, U.S. return filing, and special look-through rules on exit. The exact result depends on the character of the income, the investor’s status, and the structure used.
How BT Can Help
For more than four decades, Bennett Thrasher has provided businesses and individuals with strategic business guidance and solutions through professional tax, audit, advisory, and business process outsourcing services. Contact Trey Webb, partner in charge of Bennett Thrasher’s Real Estate and Hospitality Tax Group, or call us at 770.396.2200.
Back to Q&A
Never miss an update. Sign up to receive our monthly newsletter to unlock our experts' insights.
Subscribe Now