What are “math error notices,” and what types of errors are most common?

< Back to Q&A

Math error notices are official communications sent by the IRS to taxpayers when the agency identifies specific mathematical or clerical errors on a filed tax return. These notices inform the taxpayer that the IRS has adjusted their return by either increasing tax due, reducing a refund, or making other corrections without first going through the standard audit and deficiency procedures. The authority for the IRS to issue these notices and make such adjustments is found in Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 6213(b) and (g), which allow the IRS to bypass the usual notice of deficiency process for a specific set of errors, provided the taxpayer is notified and allowed to respond.

When a math error notice is issued, the taxpayer is typically given 60 days from the date of the notice to request an abatement of the assessment. If the taxpayer disagrees with the adjustment, they can submit documentation to substantiate their position or request abatement without substantiation. Suppose the taxpayer requests abatement within the 60-day window. In that case, the IRS must abate the assessment and, if it wishes to pursue the matter, follow the regular deficiency procedures, including issuing a statutory notice of deficiency (which allows the taxpayer to petition the U.S. Tax Court before payment is required).

Suppose the taxpayer does not respond within 60 days. In that case, the assessment becomes final, and the taxpayer loses the right to challenge the adjustment in Tax Court without first paying the tax and seeking a refund in federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims.

Types of Errors Most Commonly Leading to Math Error Notices

1. Arithmetic Mistakes: Errors in addition, subtraction, multiplication, or division on the return. For example, if a taxpayer incorrectly adds up their income or deductions, the IRS may correct the total and issue a notice.
2. Incorrect Use of Tax Tables or Schedules: If a taxpayer uses the wrong line or column in the IRS tax tables or schedules, and this is apparent from other information on the return, the IRS will correct the error.
3. Inconsistent Entries: When an entry on the return conflicts with another entry on the same return or an attached schedule or form. For example, if a taxpayer claims a credit that requires a supporting form, but the form is missing or the numbers do not match, this can trigger a math error notice.
4. Omission of Required Information: If the taxpayer omits information required to substantiate an entry, such as failing to attach Form 8863 when claiming an education credit, the IRS may issue a math error notice.
5. Exceeding Statutory Limits: If a deduction or credit claimed exceeds a statutory limit (e.g., IRA deduction limits, child tax credit limits), and the items used to calculate the limit are present on the return, the IRS will adjust the amount and issue a notice.
6. Missing or Incorrect Taxpayer Identification Numbers (TINs): This is a prevalent source of math error notices. Suppose a required TIN (such as a Social Security Number for a dependent or spouse) is missing, incorrect, or does not match IRS or Social Security Administration records. In that case, the IRS will disallow related credits or deductions and issue a notice. This is especially common for credits like the Child Tax Credit (CTC), Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC), Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), and the American Opportunity Tax Credit (AOTC).
7. Improper Claims for Certain Credits: If a taxpayer claims the EITC, CTC/ACTC, or AOTC after being previously disallowed for reckless or fraudulent claims and fails to file Form 8862 as required, the IRS will issue a math error notice.
8. Self-Employment Tax Not Paid: If a taxpayer claims the EITC based on self-employment income but has not paid the corresponding self-employment tax, this can trigger a math error notice.
9. Age Discrepancies: If the age of an individual (as determined by the TIN) does not match the age used to compute a credit (such as the CTC or EITC), the IRS may issue a notice of math error.

How Math Error Notices Work in Practice

When the IRS identifies one of these errors, it issues a math error notice (such as Notice 1462, IRS CP11, or CP12), explaining the adjustment. The notice should specify the error and inform the taxpayer of their right to request abatement within 60 days. However, in practice, these notices are sometimes unclear, and taxpayers may not always understand what was changed or how to respond. This can be particularly problematic for low-income or unsophisticated taxpayers, who may miss the opportunity to challenge the adjustment in Tax Court if they do not act promptly, as IRS errors can occur occasionally.

Conclusion Math error notices enable the IRS to promptly correct specific issues on tax returns, such as arithmetic errors, incorrect TINs, or missing information, without necessitating a full audit. If you receive one, take prompt action within 60 days to protect your rights and resolve any errors efficiently.

Back to Q&A